More Trouble with the ‘F’ Word

The President is fond of using the ‘F’ word. I’m not talking about Family or Fundamentalism. I’m talking about Faith. It’s so much softer and vaguer, so much more soothing to talk about ‘faith-based programs.’ If we called them what they are, religion-based programs, we’d all wake up. ‘Which religion?’ we would ask. ‘Are my tax dollars going to the Church of the Terminally Self-Satisfied?’ What about us atheists? Can we get tax money for our lack of faith? Why not? And all of us who follow the one true religion, do we have to subsidize heretics? Is that fair?

But ‘faith’ has such a sweet and relaxing sound. It kind of blurs everything and puts brain cells to sleep. If we are good Americans in the Bush years, we will stay narcotized except when it’s time to go shopping. I look forward to a Great Awakening soon. Here’s a story that screams like a three a.m. smoke alarm that something needs to change.

STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Although 11 year-old Madeline Kara Neumann suffered from a type of diabetes, the young Wisconsin girl’s condition was readily treatable by conventional medicine. Her parents, however, describing themselves as people of deep religious faith, opted instead to rely solely upon their prayers to God that she would be healed.

Sadly, Madeline died late last month from what an autopsy concluded was diabetic ketoacidosis, a condition characterized by inadequate insulin levels in the blood.

The questions raised by Madeline’s needless death have been asked countless times before after similar reliance on prayer alone produced similarly tragic results.

Another story on the net today…

Carl Worthington, 28, and Raylene Worthington, 25, pleaded not guilty Monday to charges of manslaughter and criminal mistreatment. They are alleged to have prayed for their 15-month-old daughter’s recovery from bacterial bronchial pneumonia and a blood infection, according to The Oregonian newspaper. Ava Worthington died March 2 at home from conditions that could have been treated with antibiotics, according to a deputy state medical examiner.

And a tragic and notorious case regarding a religious cult several years ago in Attleboro, Massachusetts.

Witnesses began appearing in front of a Bristol County grand jury last week with prosecutors hoping to prove that Robidoux’s extended following refused to nourish 18-month-old Samuel Robidoux before he died, and buried the boy alongside his stillborn cousin, Jeremiah Corneau, during an October vigil to Maine.

The point is that faith can be a bad thing when it causes people to close their eyes to reality. It’s not good to say, ‘I have faith’ as you walk off a cliff or neglect your child. With all the flaws in modern medicine, it would be a much worse system if people just took it on faith that their doctor was always right. Children would be worse off if parents weren’t skeptical and questioning and vigilant in their children’s best interest. But medicine is supposed to be evidence-based, not faith-based. That’s why it’s always changing as new information becomes available.

Faith that persists when the ground crumbles under your feet and all reasonable people turn back is not a good thing. It’s not right to ‘stay the course’ when you are on the wrong course. We have been operating on faith-based politics for too long. The language of idealism, whether it’s democracy, freedom, or faith, appeals to the heart, but we have a brain too, and we are responsible for using it.

6 thoughts on “More Trouble with the ‘F’ Word

  1. One can only wonder why those that believe their “faith” demands that they exclude medical treatment cannot just as easily believe that it was the hand of God that guided scientists to discover “medicines” or procedures that cure or heal. The sadness of course is that adults should be free to choose whether they will submit to treatment, but it is simply unjust and possibly criminal, not just madness, to deny treatment to children using the banner of religious freedom to impose harm or death on another.

  2. Unfortunately, science also says that the world was NOT created in 6 days.

    Therefore, science–of any sort–is antithetical to the Word of God.

  3. Thanks klaus…
    you just reminded me that “The Word of God” remains the Greatest Blank Check Ever Written. By Anyone. Anywhere. Anytime.

    Stupid me. I never signed up for an account.

  4. I read the bible constantly for a couple of years when i was young, and i can state with confidence that nowhere in the bible does it say not to go to doctors. there is no biblical story of someone refusing care from other people so that they can get a miraculous cure from god. none of the miraculous cure stories have any hint that it was a precondition that the sick person refuse all other remedies. the stories say the the doctor was unable to help. it happens today too.
    what worries me most is that ‘faith’ is being used to justify bad politics.
    faith is necessary, because we don’t have all the facts any of the time and we have to make choices. faith in someone’s interpretation of an ancient scripture that persists in the face of all evidence to the contrary is abdicating reason and responsibility. bad enough for yourself, but when a child is neglected it’s fair for the state to step in, no matter what the parent’s rationale.
    If someone was trying to faith-heal a broken leg it would all be easier to see.

  5. Pingback: www.buzzflash.net

Comments are closed.